AW Dev Rethought

✂️ Perfection is achieved not when there is nothing more to add, but when there is nothing left to take away - Antoine de Saint-Exupéry

Tech Drop: SpaceX Caught a Starship From Orbit. Reuse Is Still Unproven.


On Saturday, November 14, a spacecraft came back from orbit and was caught in mid-air by the tower it launched from. SpaceX’s Starship upper stage, Ship 42, settled between two mechanical arms at Starbase in South Texas about 22.5 hours after liftoff.

SpaceX had caught the rocket’s booster three times before. It had never caught the ship. NASA Administrator Jared Isaacman called it “almost magic.” The flight was not a clean success, though, and the hardest question about Starship is still unanswered.


What Happened on Flight 15

Flight 15 lifted off from Starbase on Friday evening, November 13, US time. It was Starship’s fifteenth full-scale test flight and only its second trip to orbit. The first was Flight 14 on September 28.

Ship 42 separated from its booster and reached orbit. It completed 14 laps of the Earth at about 265 km and released 26 Starlink V3 satellites along the way.

It then re-entered the atmosphere, a phase that also tested upgraded heat shield tiles. Over Starbase, it fired its engines to hover and settled between the arms at Launch Pad 2 at about 3:20 pm Texas time.

SpaceX says the heat shield held up well. Starlink satellites had photographed it in orbit before the return, and ground cameras confirmed its condition on the way down.


Why the Ship Is the Harder Catch

The booster does the first few minutes of work and turns back. The ship goes all the way to orbit. It flies higher, farther and faster than the booster, and it has to survive re-entry before it can attempt a landing at all.

That is why the earlier catches did not settle the question. A booster catch proves the tower and the arms work. A ship catch proves that a vehicle can come back from orbit and still be controlled precisely enough to meet a tower.

SpaceX had already shown it could catch a rocket. On Saturday it showed it could catch one that had been to orbit.

The catch itself is also a design choice. SpaceX says catching the vehicle on the tower allows faster inspection, refurbishment and reflight than other recovery methods. The rocket lands where it will launch from next.


The Half That Failed

The plan for Flight 15 was a double catch of booster and ship. Only the ship made it back.

The Super Heavy booster was diverted over the Gulf of Mexico shortly after launch and was lost. EarthSky reports it exploded before reaching the water.

The cause is under investigation, and the reports differ. Space.com says the booster was diverted after a low-fuel alarm. Al Jazeera quotes SpaceX’s Kate Tice saying the engines stopped firing too soon on the way down. In that account, the guidance system sensed the booster was out of position and automatically sent it toward the water.

Either way, the part SpaceX had already done three times is the part that failed. That is a useful reminder that a demonstrated capability is not yet a reliable one.


Why Reuse Is the Whole Point

Starship is 124 metres tall and is described as the largest and most powerful rocket ever built. Throwing one away after every flight would make it very expensive to fly. SpaceX’s case for the rocket depends on getting both stages back and flying them again quickly.

Several plans depend on that:

  • Starlink. The network has about 11,000 satellites today. The 52 V3 satellites from the last two flights are the first of a planned constellation of up to 100,000.
  • Starmind. SpaceX plans an AI data-centre constellation that Elon Musk says will eventually include a million spacecraft.
  • Artemis. NASA is paying billions of dollars for Starship to land astronauts on the Moon later this decade.

None of those numbers work with a rocket that flies once.


What Has Not Been Shown Yet

SpaceX’s Dan Huot said after the catch: “We caught a Starship, and now everything changes.” That may turn out to be true, but Saturday’s flight proves less than the quote suggests.

Ship 42 has been recovered. It has not flown again, and neither has any other caught ship. How much work a ship needs between flights, and how long that takes, is still unknown.

Recovery is now demonstrated. Reuse is still a claim.

The next steps are already lined up. SpaceX is expected to attempt the double catch again on the next flight. It also expects to begin launching Starships from Florida’s Kennedy Space Center within the next few months.

The flight to watch is the one where a caught ship goes back to orbit. Until that happens, Starship is a rocket that can be recovered, not yet one that can be reused.


50 Machine Learning Algorithms Cheatsheet Most downloaded free PDF 50 Machine Learning Algorithms Cheatsheet Blueprints of Intelligence — 50 ML Algorithms decoded Download free Downloaded 443 times

If this article helped you, you can support my work on AW Dev Rethought.


Rethought Relay:
Link copied!

Enjoyed this post?

Stay in the loop

New posts + weekly digest, straight to your inbox.

or

Create a free account

  • Save posts to your vault
  • Like posts & build history
  • New-post alerts

Comments

Add Your Comment

Comment Added!